Inside the Cannes Lions Direct Jury 2011.
Hell Yeah!! 25th of june. I made it back to Belgium alive. I left my home and family on tuesday the 14th of june to go and judge the direct category in Cannes for the Festival of Creativity. Me together with 24 other persons, mostly creative directors. Under the lead of Alexander Schill from ServicePlan Germany. Check the jury out here and here
I stayed at the Martinez. Hell Yeah!!! 20 metres from the Gutter Bar. Hell Yeah!!!!!! But my room had a view to a railroad. And trains were passing by at 6.30 am. Hell No!!!!!!!!
Nevertheless, wednesday we started judging.
The jury president gave a golden bullet to everyone in this jury. To make clear that we were looking for ideas and campaigns that directly hit the heart of the consumer.
Seperated in 5 little groups of 5 people each. I was with Gary (USA), Tiago (Portugal), Albert (Austria) and Raj (India) We didn’t see a lot of great work during that first day. But we did see this awesome peace of dimensional mailing from South Africa. Spark Hope. And at that point we didn’t even know that Xolisa, (the South African jury member form Joe Public Jo’burg) had something to do with it. Otherwise we wouldn’t quote it as high as we did ;-)
We saw some other cool stuff, but at the end of the day we were a bit dissappointed about the small amount of really cool stuff. Maybe 3 or 4 pieces during the whole day.
After the first day of judging we went to the Gutter Bar, we went eating . And most importantely, we were comforted by the guys and girls from the other groups: they did see more good work than we did.
After a short (that stupid train again!!) but intense sleep and a way too expensive breakfast (37 euro!!!! Luckily the organisation payed those kind of things) we were escorted to the Palais for the 2nd Judgement Day.
And what we all hoped happened. We did see more good pieces than the first day. Some belgian stuff too. Hooray!!!!! We saw the Spread the TedX campaign from Argentina
and the Budweiser Poolball campaign, also from Argentina.
These guys suck at football but they sure know how to make great ads. Or is it the other way around? Later that week we found out that these 2 lovely campaigns came from argentinian jury member German Yunes’s agency (Ogilvy Argentina) Arriba German!!!
That evening and night, same routine. Gutter Bar, dinner, gutter bar, sleep, 6.30 train. Aaaagh!!! Stupid train!!
Day 3. Switching groups again. During the session in my group we judged work from my agency and more specifically from me and my copywriter @imanava
Radio1-Revenge on Callcenters
<p>Radio 1 - Revenge on callcenters & helpdesks from Mortierbrigade on Vimeo.</p>
and Studio Brussel-Share Your Parents
<p>Studio Brussel - Music For Life - share your parents from Mortierbrigade on Vimeo.</p>
Never felt so small in my life. But my group seemed to like it. At least that’s what they told me. I would get to know if they were talking the truth the next day, during shortlist discussions.
And that next day arrived as fast as the train that woke me up the next morning at... 6.30
Saturday morning – Day 4 – Shortlist Day.
The organisation gave us a pile of paper with all the shortlisted campaigns on it.
I quickly browsed it and counted 20 shortlists for Belgium. Almost as much shortlist as inhabitants. Nice! And from those 20 shortlists, 8 were from my agency: mortierbrigade brussels. And guess what? The people from my group didn’t lie. They really liked our work. Radio1-Revenge on callcenters and Studio Brussel-Share Your Parents were shortlisted 2 times each. Another campaign from me and my copywriter made it to the shortlist. Share If You Care – A fundraising facebook app for Pakistan.
<p>Share if you care from Mortierbrigade on Vimeo.</p>
I was a happy camper.
When we took a look at the rest of the shortlist I noticed that a lot of great work was on it. Spark Hope was on it, the Spread the TedX was on it...
After a brief chat we started to walk around the room and began to give points to every campaign that was on the shortlist. It was there that I discovered some campaigns I didn’t see during my first 3 days of judging. Just to name a few: Coca Cola friendship machine (Ogilvy Argentina and German again!! Aiai Cabron!!),
American Rom (a really ballsy campaign from Romania)
and Tesco – Subway Stores from Cheill Worldwide Seoul, a real piece of innovation.
We had a long day of judging and discussions and after a short break around 6 o’clock we entered the room again. We got to see the points and the rankings and then we discussed about some works that we wanted to bring into the shortlist again. I was glad to see that Budweiser Poolball finally made it to the shortlist.
We called it a day at euhmm... almost midnight and went for some pizza. Went to sleep at 2am and woke up at 6.30 because of a stupid train.
Sunday – Lions Day. Today we were gonna give Lions to the campaigns. Exciting.
Raul Perez (Spain) was sitting on my left and Tony Bradbourne (New Zealand and aka the man who made the Iggy Pop Direct GP 2010) was sitting to my right. ROCK ON!!!
We had some discussions during the day but in the end everyone agreed on most of the Lions. We had 11 golds which is OK but not a lot when you know that over 1800 campaigns have been entered.
Golds for Tesco,
Coca Cola Friendship machine,
Human Rights Watch, - Burma,
American Rom,
Decode Jay-Z.
We handed out more silvers and a lot more Bronzes.
When the jury voted on my campaigns (from my agency or from me and my copywriter) I had to go outside. And I can assure you, those were the worst minutes of my entire young life. In the hallway you feel a mixture of all kinds of body liquids searching for a way to get out. When finally they let you back into the room everybody has a pokerface. In that case your campaign remains shortlist. When your campaign has a lion, some of the guys lift their thumbs up. And those moments with thumbs up were the best moments of my entire young life. The result: 3 bronze lions for yours truly and his copywriter. And 6 bronze lions for Belgium. Together with the 20 shortlist Belgium is ranked 6th country in the direct jury. Not bad for a country without a government.
After handing out all those lions we took a break and we came back for another important round. We were about to judge for the Grand Prix.
After one hour of debate, discussions and judging pro’s en contra’s we unanimously awarded American Rom with the Grand Prix. Why?? Because it was as good as the other contenders for the Grand Prix. With a little difference. This campaign showed a lot of courage from the client’s side. The brand was in deep shit and they took a serious risk by running this campaign. But it worked out and we wanted to show the advertisers all over the planet that sometimes it pays to follow your instinct and to just put your balls on the table!!
So that was that.
We were finished at 10PM
We went to eat something with some of the jury members and got a good night sleep.
When I woke up at 6.30 because of the train, I wasn’t angry at the train no more. How can one be angry about a train when we just awarded a Gold Lion to this campaign about a miniature train. Enjoy the Come Back Ferrorama-campaign.
Many thanks to the jury with the most down to earth people ever!!!!
Cheers,


